В маленьком эссе, которое, казалось бы, не имеет ко мне вообще никакого отношения, потому что предназначено для организаторов и ведущих литературных диспутов, вещаемых на широкую аудиторию, стало быть по телевидению, или на радио, я нашла-таки для себя кое-что большее и довольно универсальное, как человеческое общение под увеличительным стеклом. Может не любое общение, но часто. Конечно, в рамках передачи каждый стремится прежде всего высказаться. В жизни предоставляется обычно больше времени, чтобы слушать других. И тем не менее, я считаю , что подобный диспут - это жизненное общение в конденсированном виде. Регламента может не быть никакого, личные (или общие, если это коллектив) цели иметь или не иметь место, в обыденном общении чаще - хаотично, непоследовательно, но каждый считает себя той персоной, которая несет в себе истину, независимо от того, высказывает он свое мнение окружающим, или нет. Той самой важной и значимой персоной, которая должна что-то доказывать миру, по большому счету забыв обо всех остальных.

Как сказал персонаж комиксов Лекс Лютор с легкой руки его создателей \"Одни, прочитав «Войну и мир», решают, что это приключенческий роман, а другие, читая состав на обертке от жвачки, постигают тайны Вселенной.\" И это неплохо работает как для читателя, который постигая законы Вселенной по фантику дает фантику очень высокую цену, так и для писателя, когда читатель так высоко ценит то, что он создал. А кто сказал, что цветастый фантик - менее ценен, чем тома какой-нибудь Всемирной энциклопедии?

","user_display_name":"Corlija","user_avatar_url":null,"user_is_verified":false,"user_role":null,"user_id":25550570,"is_comment_left_by_reviewed_person":null,"created_at":"2024-03-13T16:12:09","likes_rating":0,"likes_count":0,"dislikes_count":0,"is_liked_by_current_user":false,"is_disliked_by_current_user":false,"is_removed_by_moderator":false,"black_listed_by_user":false,"item_rating":4,"replies":[],"is_user_profile_clickable":false,"source":"livelib","replies_count":0},{"id":4455356,"caption":null,"text":"

Отличная книга, очень помогла мне. Нашла все ответы на свои вопросы, но если необходим более подробный материал, ищите другую литературу…

","user_display_name":"Poksyakinaa","user_avatar_url":null,"user_is_verified":false,"user_role":null,"user_id":527933479,"is_comment_left_by_reviewed_person":null,"created_at":"2019-06-13T22:22:46","likes_rating":0,"likes_count":0,"dislikes_count":0,"is_liked_by_current_user":false,"is_disliked_by_current_user":false,"is_removed_by_moderator":false,"black_listed_by_user":false,"item_rating":5,"replies":[],"is_user_profile_clickable":true,"source":"litres","replies_count":0},{"id":3203,"caption":null,"text":"

То, что, к сожалению, необходимо посетителям многих интернет-библиотек. Инструкция о культуре ведения той самой дискуссии. Кого не учили – покупайте.

","user_display_name":"аннита","user_avatar_url":null,"user_is_verified":false,"user_role":null,"user_id":147391,"is_comment_left_by_reviewed_person":null,"created_at":"2009-02-18T11:28:51","likes_rating":0,"likes_count":0,"dislikes_count":0,"is_liked_by_current_user":false,"is_disliked_by_current_user":false,"is_removed_by_moderator":false,"black_listed_by_user":false,"item_rating":null,"replies":[],"is_user_profile_clickable":true,"source":"litres","replies_count":0},{"id":807,"caption":"А где более подробная информация??? ","text":"

Господа, не хватает информации. Ни нормально рецензии, ни содержания... Я бы купил, подобное мне нужно, но кота в мешке приобретать не хочется.

","user_display_name":"tekilla333","user_avatar_url":null,"user_is_verified":false,"user_role":null,"user_id":33626,"is_comment_left_by_reviewed_person":null,"created_at":"2008-05-30T10:41:26","likes_rating":0,"likes_count":0,"dislikes_count":0,"is_liked_by_current_user":false,"is_disliked_by_current_user":false,"is_removed_by_moderator":false,"black_listed_by_user":false,"item_rating":null,"replies":[],"is_user_profile_clickable":true,"source":"litres","replies_count":0}]}},"fulfilledTimeStamp":1744098671327},"getArtQuotes({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"url\":\"\"})":{"status":"fulfilled","endpointName":"getArtQuotes","requestId":"mo4aWVbz8n972HadkUbw_","originalArgs":{"artId":165460,"url":"","limit":5},"startedTimeStamp":1744098671265,"data":{"status":200,"error":null,"payload":{"pagination":{"next_page":null,"previous_page":null},"data":[],"total_count":0}},"fulfilledTimeStamp":1744098671352},"getArtJournalCollection({\"artIdOrSlug\":165460})":{"status":"fulfilled","endpointName":"getArtJournalCollection","requestId":"0aDsc03viMnhyJE7-x-Km","originalArgs":{"artIdOrSlug":165460},"startedTimeStamp":1744098671265,"data":[],"fulfilledTimeStamp":1744098671298}},"mutations":{},"provided":{"Offer":{"FOUR-ART-GIFT":["getFourArtOffer(undefined)"]},"ArtShortList":{"167948":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"167949":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"167950":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"167951":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"28744765":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"31265813":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"64061616":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"65803098":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"66553836":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"66772558":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"67987280":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"69270262":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"69394804":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"70542592":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"70731322":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"70824085":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"70824091":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"70872548":["getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"],"71398264":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"71448760":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})"],"__internal_without_id":["getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})","getSeriesArtsByArtId({\"artId\":165460,\"art_groups\":[1],\"limit\":100,\"o\":\"order_in_series_desc\"})","getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})"]},"Art":{"807":["getArtReviews({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"sortType\":\"popular\",\"url\":\"\"})"],"3203":["getArtReviews({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"sortType\":\"popular\",\"url\":\"\"})"],"165460":["getArtData({\"artIdOrSlug\":165460})"],"4455356":["getArtReviews({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"sortType\":\"popular\",\"url\":\"\"})"],"18503299":["getArtReviews({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"sortType\":\"popular\",\"url\":\"\"})"],"LIST":["getArtReviews({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"sortType\":\"popular\",\"url\":\"\"})"]}},"subscriptions":{"getAbTests({\"SID\":\"66de720yf91y49b5dfbj59ag5u4y6405\"})":{"iaYxwLzqEP7i5CPwVMScW":{}},"getBanners({\"place\":\"web-header-full-width\"})":{"Zbffc-Gk2OCsc8HbhLtvx":{}},"getUserDataForSSR(\"66de720yf91y49b5dfbj59ag5u4y6405\")":{"jOST3KCjK9FhDI3kXoaxZ":{}},"getArtData({\"artIdOrSlug\":165460})":{"CAU-GAxMTGa-9kn90vVP1":{}},"getSubscriptionPrices({\"subscriptionType\":14})":{"xBEuh2WgAF5Jv-CT62y6R":{}},"getUserSubscriptionsInfo(null)":{"LXGDeU2JJIIOU1P7_NJ1r":{}},"getUserAbonementInfo(null)":{"XDqcMOJQ9931CU1LBFvVm":{}},"getArtFiles({\"artId\":165460})":{"TiTuQYwrUztmEAvlxkaJZ":{}},"getFourArtOffer(undefined)":{"vknxhwlrdVbJqz9p-2Ibq":{}},"getSeriesArtsByArtId({\"artId\":165460,\"art_groups\":[1],\"limit\":100,\"o\":\"order_in_series_desc\"})":{"ALt2GYRrfAzwuh7k7qL6l":{}},"getSimilarArtsForRecommendation({\"artIDorSlug\":165460,\"limit\":10})":{"x0wv7P365zWhnzb7SCIch":{}},"getPersonArts({\"authorIdOrSlug\":\"aleksandr-mazin\",\"limit\":10})":{"NcDL-GmGMi_l61T_L_n9l":{}},"getOftenSearched({\"itemId\":165460})":{"-TsWnLrD4SfHY5-R194uQ":{}},"getArtReviews({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"sortType\":\"popular\",\"url\":\"\"})":{"sZATRokSRZkDMVnu4YZzk":{}},"getArtQuotes({\"artId\":165460,\"limit\":5,\"url\":\"\"})":{"mo4aWVbz8n972HadkUbw_":{}},"getArtJournalCollection({\"artIdOrSlug\":165460})":{"0aDsc03viMnhyJE7-x-Km":{}}},"config":{"online":true,"focused":true,"middlewareRegistered":true,"refetchOnFocus":false,"refetchOnReconnect":false,"refetchOnMountOrArgChange":false,"keepUnusedDataFor":60,"reducerPath":"rtkqApi"}},"HeadHunterApi":{"queries":{},"mutations":{},"provided":{},"subscriptions":{},"config":{"online":true,"focused":true,"middlewareRegistered":true,"refetchOnFocus":false,"refetchOnReconnect":false,"refetchOnMountOrArgChange":false,"keepUnusedDataFor":60,"reducerPath":"HeadHunterApi"}},"user":{"accountSettings":{"actions":{"changePasswordCSRF":{},"changeProfilePrivacyCSRF":{},"setMarketingConsentCSRF":{}}},"credentials":{"isAnon":true,"userID":"0","userSID":"anonimous-empty-sid","name":"Anonymous","groups":[8,16],"lfrom":"","actions":{"changeCredentialsCSRF":{}}},"balance":{"account":0,"bonus":0,"accountFull":0},"basket":{"inBasket":0,"inDeferred":0,"purchased":0},"library":{},"boughtCollections":{"collections":[]},"notifications":{"isLoading":false,"unreadedCount":0,"allCount":0,"list":[]},"abonement":{"active":false,"price":"399"},"subscription":{"subscriptionClass":[{"id":1,"trial":true,"month":1,"price":"0","pricePerMonth":"0","basePrice":"399"},{"id":2,"trial":false,"month":1,"price":"399","pricePerMonth":"399","basePrice":"399"}],"active":false},"partnersSubscriptions":{"isAnyPartnerSubscriptionActive":false,"isMegafonSubscriptionActive":false,"isRostelecomSubscriptionActive":false,"isYotaSubscriptionActive":false,"isA1SubscriptionActive":false,"isKCellSubscriptionActive":false,"isInlabSubscriptionActive":false,"isTinkoffSubscriptionActive":false,"isLifebelSubscriptionActive":false},"socnet":{"attachedSocnets":[]},"avatar":{"availability":false,"avatarHash":"233","actions":{"uploadAvatarCSRF":{}}},"tests":{},"webpushes":{"status":false},"offers":{"offersList":[]},"actions":{"updateMyRegCSRF":{},"uniteUsersCSRF":{}},"authorization":{"actions":{"checkPassCorrectCSRF":{},"otpinLoginCSRF":{},"loginCSRF":{},"attachSocnetCSRF":{},"socnetCSRF":{},"checkSocnetCSRF":{}}},"registration":{"actions":{"checkEmailAvailabilityGUJ":{},"verifyPhoneCSRF":{},"recoverPasswordCSRF":{},"registrationCSRF":{}}},"rebills":{"list":{},"actions":{"deletePaymentCardCSRF":{},"getRebillsGUJ":{}}}},"foundationUser":{"id":0,"login":"","BSK":[],"LKS":[],"is_staff":false,"isOfficeUser":false,"profile":{"has_folder_arts":false},"account":{"display":0,"real":0,"full":0,"bonus":0},"settings":{"profile_privacy":"default","is_safemode_enabled":null},"socials":[],"library_info":{"title":null,"logo":{},"host":null,"is_school_user":false},"abonement":{"id":null,"is_active":false,"price":null,"rebill_id":null,"valid_till":null,"grace_period_start":null,"gift_arts_refresh_at":null,"payment_system_id":null,"purchase_origin":null},"subscription":{"id":null,"grace_period_start":null,"rebill_id":null,"payment_system_id":null,"purchase_origin":null},"partner_subscriptions":{"has_active":false,"subscriptions":[]},"phone":{},"ab_tests":[],"isLoading":false,"error":{},"isAsking":false,"actions":{"teleport_CSRF":{}},"varioqubTests":{"ymabParam":"","flags":{},"testIds":[],"initialized":false,"initializingError":false},"loyalty":{"is_loyalty_user":false,"bonuses_info":null},"is_tester":false,"SID":"66de720yf91y49b5dfbj59ag5u4y6405"},"browser":{"screen":{"width":null,"height":null},"urlParams":{},"pda":false,"clientHost":"www.litres.ru","headers":{"client-host":"www.litres.ru","ui-currency":"RUB","Ui-Language-Code":"ru","x-request-id":"abf572c79daacc19b5f931378c37c4a9","Basket":"","Wishlist":"","Session-Id":"66de720yf91y49b5dfbj59ag5u4y6405"},"isRobot":true},"player":{"data":{"playerSettings":{"url":"","drm3key":"","isPlaying":false,"volume":0.5,"playbackRate":1,"muted":false,"isContentsOpen":false,"downloadForbidden":false,"readOnly":false,"isAnon":true,"isChapterLoading":false,"contentsData":[]},"currentTime":0,"playerData":{"error":null,"event":null,"isReady":false,"loadedTime":0,"duration":0,"totalDuration":0,"isHalf":false,"canBackward":false,"canForward":true,"stats":{"hits":0,"secondsListened":0}}},"notes":{"order":0}},"payment":null,"pages":{"personalCabinet":{"paymentsHistory":{"payments":{"paginator":{"page":0,"limit":0,"maxPageNumber":0,"items":0},"pages":[]},"actions":{"paymentsHistoryCSRF":{}}},"userLibraries":{"libraries":[],"actions":{"teleportCSRF":{},"unsubscribeCSRF":{},"uniteCSRF":{},"uniteCSRFV2":{},"getUserLibrariesCSRF":{}}},"loyaltyCards":{"list":[],"actions":{"changeLoyaltyCSRF":{},"getLoyaltyCardsCSRF":{}}},"spam":{"userChannels":[],"userLangs":[],"actions":{"updateChannelsCSRF":{},"getUserChannelsGUJ":{},"getUserLangsGUJ":{}}},"bonuses":{"bonusExpiration":[],"actions":{"getBonusExpirationGUJ":{}}}},"paymentReceipts":{"receipts":[],"actions":{"getPaymentReceipts":{}}}},"global":{"auth":{"activeStep":"authenticationByEmail","fallbackStep":"init","stepsHistory":[],"formData":{},"isRateLimitError":false},"header":{"auth":{"isAuthPopupVisible":false,"analyticsData":{}},"banners":{"subscr":{"isActive":false},"onlyLitres":{"isActive":false},"promotion":{"isActive":false},"audioSubscr":{"isActive":false},"tvCampaignBanner":{"isActive":false}}},"globalModals":{"visibilityState":"init"},"availableBonuses":{"list":{},"actions":{"getAvailableBonusesListGUJ":{}}},"login":{"authValues":{"code":"","email":"","pwd":"","phoneCode":{"id":"91","tel_codes":[{"tel_mask":"7 XXX XXX XX XX","tel_code":"7"}],"code":"RU","name":"Россия"},"phone":"","otpin":""},"activeStep":"welcome","strategy":"email","isBiblioLogin":false,"isOldUser":false,"isVerifyPhone":false,"isLoading":false,"loginFormat":"email","passRecovery":{"method":"email","isTimerActive":false},"prevSteps":["welcome"],"usersMerges":false,"isLoginReserved":false,"serverError":null},"search":{"query":"","searchResults":[],"history":[],"loading":false,"error":{},"isInitiated":false},"interface":{"loginPopupError":{"isOpen":false},"stickyPlayer":{"isOpen":false},"isPageWithPlayer":true,"checkoutBox":{"isOpen":false,"height":0},"helpdesk":{"isOpen":false},"spamTickets":{"isOpen":false,"isHtmlFetched":false},"paymentPopup":{"isOpen":false},"reviewComplainPopup":{"isOpen":false,"id":0},"forceScroll":{"scrollToReviewForm":false,"scrollToReviewId":0},"sharingPopup":{"reviewId":0,"userName":"","userId":0,"rating":0,"comment":"","date":"","hasAvatar":false,"isOpen":false,"isReply":false},"headerHeight":0},"lastViewedBooksWidget":{"arts":[],"isLoading":false,"error":null},"phonecodes":{"countriez":"","actions":{"getPhonecodes":{"isLoading":false}}},"onboarding":{"isOpen":false},"genres":{"popup":{"history":[],"currentGenre":null,"isOpen":false}},"arts":{"details":{"xmlProps":null},"reviews":{"list":[],"idMap":{},"sortType":"popular","pagination":{"next":null,"previous":null},"userReview":null,"lastGetRequestDate":"Tue Apr 08 2025 07:28:10 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)","actions":{"getArtsReviews":{},"addArtsReview":{},"getUserArtsReviews":{},"addArtReviewLike":{},"removeArtReviewLike":{},"addArtReviewDislike":{},"removeArtReviewDislike":{},"addReviewReply":{}}}},"take":{"take":{"actions":{"takeBookCSRF":{}},"rating":[]}},"reviews":{"actions":{"addReviewComplain":{}},"activeReply":-1},"searchPage":{"query":""},"zeroSearchPage":{"recommendationBlocks":[],"loading":false,"error":{},"isListInitiated":false,"isInfoInitiated":false,"data":{"art_slider":{"data":[],"pagination":{"next_page":null,"previous_page":null},"loading":false},"person_list":{"data":[],"pagination":{"next_page":null,"previous_page":null},"loading":false},"series_list":{"data":[],"pagination":{"next_page":null,"previous_page":null},"loading":false},"tag_list":{"data":[],"pagination":{"next_page":null,"previous_page":null},"loading":false}}}},"face":{"language":"ru","host":null}}